The manager’s guide to a supportive conversation
Most managers know roughly what to look for and freeze at the point of saying something. This guide is about that moment: what to notice, how to open it, what to say when you are worried and where to point someone next.
If you are worried about someone right now
These are free and available to anyone, and they are not behind the form below. If you need them, use them and read the rest later.
You are not being asked to diagnose anyone, fix anything or carry it alone. The part of this that belongs to a manager is small and specific: notice a change, say something early, listen properly and know where to point. That is all this guide covers.
Enter your details to read the full guide
The rest of the guide covers what a manager’s role is and is not, then all seven steps: the changes worth noticing, how to open the conversation, the second ask, what to do when you are worried about someone’s safety and what happens afterwards. One-off, you won’t need to do this again on this device.
What this is, and what it is not
The single biggest reason managers say nothing is a belief that saying something makes them responsible for whatever comes next. It does not.
You are not the treatment
You are not a counsellor, a therapist or a clinician, and nothing here asks you to behave like one. Your job is to notice, to ask, to listen and to know where to point. The help itself comes from somewhere else: a GP, an EAP, occupational health, Samaritans, the NHS. Managers who understand this speak up sooner, because the thing they were afraid of taking on was never theirs to take on.
Noticing is genuinely yours, though
The part that does belong to you is the part nobody else can do. You see this person most weekdays. You know what normal looks like for them, which means you are one of very few people positioned to spot that it has changed. A colleague, a friend or a family member might see a bad day. You see the pattern. That is not a clinical skill. It is familiarity, and it is worth acting on.
In the sessions we run, managers almost never report anyone taking offence at being asked kindly whether they were alright. What people describe is the opposite: long periods where they were visibly struggling and nobody said anything, and reading that silence as not mattering. The risk of asking is small and social. The risk of not asking is not.
Seven steps, from noticing to what happens next
This is written to be read once and remembered in the moment. Step six is the one most people skip, and it is the one that matters most on the days it applies.
Notice the change, not the personality
You are not looking for someone who seems like a person who struggles. You are looking for a difference from their own normal, sustained over a couple of weeks. Someone usually early who is now often late. Someone talkative who has gone quiet, or someone quiet who has become uncharacteristically sharp. Work that used to be reliable and is now slipping. Camera off in every meeting when it never used to be. Lunch alone, when they always used to go with the team. Any one of these is nothing. A cluster of them, lasting a fortnight, is worth a conversation.
- The test: is this different from how they usually are, and has it lasted more than a week or two?
Choose the moment and the place deliberately
Not in front of the team, not in a glass-walled meeting room where everyone can see and not in the last five minutes of a one to one that was mostly about deadlines. Side by side is easier than across a desk, which is why a walk or a coffee outside the building works so well: it removes the eye contact that makes this hard, and it gives the conversation somewhere to go if it needs longer than expected. Give it more time than you think you need, and make sure you are not about to be interrupted.
- If you cannot find privacy and time this week, that is the thing to fix first. Do not have it badly because the diary was full.
Open with what you have seen, not what you think it means
Name the observation, keep it specific and factual, then stop. “I have noticed you have seemed quite quiet in the last few weeks, and you have been in much later than usual. How are you doing?” That works because it is evidently true, it is not an accusation, and it does not require the other person to accept a label before they can answer. What does not work is a diagnosis in the opening line. “Are you depressed?” and “you seem really stressed” both ask someone to agree to a description of themselves, and the easiest way out of that is to say they are fine.
- The shape: one observation, one open question, then silence. Let the pause do the work rather than filling it.
Ask a second time
The first answer is almost always “I’m fine”. That is a reflex rather than information, and it is the point at which most managers accept the answer and leave. Ask again, once, gently and without pressing: “I’m glad. I did just want to check, because you have not seemed quite yourself recently and I would rather ask than assume.” The second ask is what signals that the first question was not a formality. People often describe telling somebody for the first time only because that person asked twice.
- Ask twice, never three times. If the answer is still no, leave the door open and come back in a fortnight.
Listen, and hold off on solving it
If someone does start talking, the strongest thing you can do is very little. Do not fill silences, do not match their story with one of your own and do not start problem-solving in the first two minutes, which is the most common way a good conversation gets closed down. Being listened to without being managed is, for most people, the actual value of the conversation. Two phrases carry a lot of weight here: “that sounds really hard” and “thank you for telling me”. Neither commits you to anything and both land properly.
- Avoid “at least”, “have you tried” and “I know exactly how you feel”. All three move the conversation back to you.
If you are genuinely worried about their safety, ask directly
This is the step people skip, usually because they are afraid that raising it might put the idea in someone’s head. It does not work that way. Asking someone directly whether they are having thoughts of suicide does not increase the risk, and it is very often a relief to be asked, because it makes the unsayable thing sayable. Ask plainly and without euphemism: “Are you having thoughts of suicide?” Then listen to the answer, do not react with alarm, and do not leave them alone while you work out what to do. You are not being asked to resolve it. You are being asked not to look away from it.
- If the answer is yes: stay with them, and go through the options together. Samaritans on 116 123, NHS 111 and the mental health option, their GP. If their life is at immediate risk, 999 or A&E.
- Do not promise to keep it secret before you know what you are being told. Say instead that you will not share more widely than you have to.
Agree one next step, then actually do your half of it
End with something specific and small rather than a general offer of support, which tends to evaporate the moment the conversation does. One next step, named, with who is doing it and by when. Perhaps they will call the EAP this week. Perhaps you will take two things off their workload by Friday, or move the client meeting. Perhaps the only step is that the two of you will speak again next Tuesday. Then put it in your own diary and do it. The thing that damages trust is not having the conversation badly. It is having it well and then nothing changing.
- Book the follow-up before you leave the room. A vague “my door is always open” puts the effort back on the person least able to make it.
These conversations stay with the person who had them. If you have just sat with something heavy, talk to your own manager, your HR contact or your own EAP, in general terms and without naming anybody unnecessarily. Managers who are carrying several of these quietly and alone are the ones who stop having them, and the organisation only finds out much later.
Give your managers the confidence to notice and respond
Reading this once helps. Practising it is what makes it available under pressure. Our Mental Health for Managers session works through these conversations properly, including the ones people are most afraid of getting wrong. Half a day, onsite or online, tailored before delivery.
Find out about Mental Health for ManagersThis guide is general information for employers and people leaders. It is not clinical guidance, it is not a substitute for professional help, and it does not make a manager responsible for anyone’s safety. If you are worried about someone, Samaritans is free on 116 123, day or night, and NHS 111 will direct you to the right service. If someone’s life is at risk, call 999. Related reading: our post on noticing when a colleague is struggling. Every session is tailored to your organisation before delivery.